Every time I take on an assignment for a trader one of the criteria required is usually someone with a transferable book of clients. Most want a plug-and-play candidate that can pick up the ball and run straight away. One with a neatly packaged book of clients that will follow complete with a red ribbon.

In the marine fuels market, a trader’s “book” is less a formal asset than a live portfolio of relationships. These are with shipowners, operators and charterers who buy fuel regularly; the suppliers and physical counterparties who can actually deliver; credit intelligence; and hard-won knowledge of which ports, grades and vessels can be worked profitably.

To a competitor, that book can represent immediate volume, and a shortcut past years of time-consuming relationship-building. Its real worth, however, is highly variable and rarely equals a simple multiple of historical revenue.

Bunker trading is a high-volume, low-margin business. Traders typically buy from physical suppliers and resell to end users, taking title to the fuel and the associated credit risk while earning a spread. This value comes from three areas:

First is the customer base itself, for example Singapore-based shipowners, Florida-based liner companies or niche offshore operators.

Second is the supplier and logistics network that turns an enquiry into a reliable stem.

Third is the credit decision that lets a trader extend terms without accumulating massive debts that can erase the profit on many successful stems.

It is worth noting here that two traders selling the same fuel at the same price can have very different books; the one with deeper trust and port-specific knowledge is the more valuable asset.

Competitors value such books because they compress time and mitigate risk. A firm that hires a trader with an established, transferable portfolio can add volume without building the network from the ground up, improve its supplier leverage, and gain market knowledge even in a data-rich era.

This is why firms routinely offer higher base salaries, better commission or shares, and relocation packages when a candidate can bring a profitable client portfolio. Average total compensation for bunker traders sits at over US$150,000 globally, but seniors with proven books command materially more through variable pay.

Quantifying the value is difficult and there is no standard industry multiple here. A practical approach treats the book as expected future contribution margin discounted for retention risk. If a trader’s book generates a certain annual gross profit, a competitor might pay higher compensation, partly for the strategic value of the volume and relationships. Retention is the critical variable: many clients follow the person rather than the firm, but not all do. Non-compete or non-solicitation clauses, the personal nature of trust, price sensitivity, and the client’s existing relationships with other suppliers all reduce the percentage of clients that actually make the move.

Credit profile is equally important. A large book heavy with higher-risk counterparties can be a liability as much as an asset, given that a single default can cause substantial damage.

Putting numbers on it, take a trader with a book of 200,000 metric tonnes a year at a blended average margin of US$3 per tonne. That is a gross contribution of US$600,000 a year.

How much of that moves with the trader? There is no published industry-wide statistic, but the market is personal, and one person moving from a key role can affect an entire book. For a well-managed mid-market book, first-year retention of volume and profit is roughly 50-70%, but could sink as low as 40%. It is higher only where the relationships are deep and personal, and the new firm’s credit lines and risk appetite align to retain them. Larger institutional buyers tend to be loyal to the firm, while smaller and mid-size buyers tend to be loyal to the person. A reasonable base rate is therefore 60%, which puts the transferred first-year contribution at US$600,000 x 60% = US$360,000.

What might a firm pay for that? On compensation, a higher base plus a transparent share of attributable P&L, commonly in the 20-40% range for a proven book. On top of that comes a hiring premium: an elevated total package (base plus expected variable) that can equal 0.5 to 1.5 times the expected first-year transferred profit. If retention then holds or improves, because the new firm can offer better pricing, credit, or service, the multi-year contribution grows.

So a 200,000 tonne book at US$3 per tonne margin is worth several hundred thousand dollars of annual contribution if a realistic share of the book moves with the trader. The exact amount depends on how much of the portfolio is loyal to the trader and how much is loyal to the firm they work for, and what the hiring firm’s ability is to retain margins and service the incoming business.

Additional factors also come into play to shape the number.

If the trader has a niche specialisation (certain ports, fuel grades or vessel types) and exclusive or hard-to-replicate supplier relationships, these will increase their value. Low margins, fuel-price volatility, and the ease with which tech-savvy buyers now compare quotes via digital platforms decrease it.

Legal and practical constraints matter too. Enforceable non-competes limit immediate revenue opportunities, while the operational integration of credit lines and systems can either amplify or dilute the book’s contribution once the trader joins a new firm.

In short, a strong bunker trader’s book is often worth a substantial competitive premium, enough to justify elevated pay, but it is not a freely transferable balance-sheet asset. Its realised value to a competitor depends less on the list of names than on the trader’s ability to migrate the underlying trust, the quality of the counterparties, and the new firm’s capacity to support the business without eroding margins, credit standards, and overall reputation.

In a relationship-driven market with thin spreads, it is that human and operational element which is the largest determinant of what the book is ultimately worth.

I am here if you need me.