• US and EU now diverge on Russian diesel, so one cargo can be lawful under one regime and not the other
  • Suppliers "have to navigate multiple regimes simultaneously", says Peninsula
  • Compliance is checked through the life of the deal, "not simply at the moment the deal is fixed"

Diverging US and EU sanctions policy on Russian product means a bunker supplier now has to clear the same transaction under more than one set of rules, and keep checking it after the deal is done, according to Peninsula.

"Sanctions compliance is becoming more complex given the increase in frequency of major geopolitical events," Zain Hudda, Deputy General Counsel at Peninsula, told Ship & Bunker.

"As a result, rules and regulations move quickly and we are increasingly seeing additional complexities due to the divergence in policy between the US and other global regulators, meaning companies like ours have to navigate multiple regimes simultaneously."

The recent OFAC waiver on Russian diesel is the clearest example, he said, as the US has made a concession that the EU has not.

It means a cargo that is now lawful for a US-regulated party remains off limits under EU rules.

"We have a responsibility to comply with rules simultaneously," he said.

The result is that over the course of a stem, companies have to navigate not only multiple sanctions regimes, but regimes that are evolving independently.

For Peninsula, the answer is that compliance cannot stop at fixing, because the rules, and the facts of a voyage, can change after it.

"In a regulatory environment that keeps moving, the objective is therefore not simply to be compliant at the moment the deal is fixed. It is to have enough layers of screening, documentation, contractual protection, monitoring and legal oversight to identify when the risk changes and respond accordingly," Hudda said. He added that the legal and regulatory framework is only one consideration, noting that the global banking system requires careful adherence and constant communication. “We take the view that our banking group are partners in policing sanctions policy and practice. We often provide pro-active market intelligence and the benefit of our sector expertise to help banks manage this complex area.”

"That robust framework operates throughout the transaction lifecycle, from leading KYC and vessel screening to assessing the underlying trade and monitoring activity after delivery.

"Our policies, procedures and systems are supported by established, externally audited processes, significant internal expertise and tools such as WorldCheck and Windward."

Cat and Mouse

Alongside the increasingly complex sanctions landscape, the number of warning signs a supplier has to consider when screening a vessel is growing too.

From unusual AIS activity and changes of vessel name or flag, to non-Russian vessels that may legitimately be carrying Russian oil or petroleum products, the task is getting harder.

"The game of 'cat and mouse' between regulators and sanctions evaders will get even more sophisticated," Hudda warned.

"Context is everything, and by working with the right type of customers who are willing to provide us with comfort on the legality of their voyages, we can stay compliant."

In practice, that means Peninsula separates what its customers may lawfully carry from what it is prepared to trade itself.

"There is a fundamental difference between bunkering a vessel lawfully carrying Russian-origin product and Peninsula buying or selling that product itself - diesel or otherwise," he said.

"We continue to prohibit Russian-origin products from our physical supply portfolio as we have done since the Ukraine conflict began."

Being a physical supplier in many ports helps with that, he said, as it "affords us a greater ability to control the origins of product being used in our operations." Hudda added a further consideration saying “whilst we are clearly focused on ensuring compliant customers, it is equally important for ship operators to be content with supplier and trader policies re sanctions. You don’t want your ship caught up in disruption caused by a bunker supplier or trader failing on their compliance governance.”

Where Peninsula differentiates itself, Hudda said, is that sanctions compliance has been embedded in the business for many years, not created as a reaction to current global events.

"This all emanates from Peninsula's senior leadership, so has been a longstanding part of our risk and compliance culture and predates the Ukraine conflict," he said.