The Clean Shipping Alliance (CSA), a coalition of shipping companies that support the use of scrubber systems, has questioned the basis for Greenland's phased restrictions on discharges of washwater from scrubber systems.

Greenland's Parliament has recommended the adoption of a proposal to prohibit discharges from open-loop scrubbers in the country's port areas, inland waters and territorial waters from July 1, 2027.

The restrictions would be extended to all other scrubber systems, including closed-loop systems, from July 1, 2029.

“We are disappointed to see Greenland announce restrictions on exhaust gas cleaning systems (EGCS, or ‘scrubbers’), starting in 2027,” Andreas Chrysostomou, executive director of CSA, said in an emailed statement on Wednesday.

He questioned which specific risks Greenland had identified from scrubber discharges and how it had assessed them.

Chrysostomou added that the IMO's MEPC.1/Circ.899 provides an agreed method for evaluating local risks, including receiving environments, discharge composition, dilution and ecotoxicity.

He added that “a precautionary approach cannot replace the assessment that the IMO framework calls for”.

Chrysostomou also said that scrubbers reduce sulphur and other substances released into the air, as well as particulate matter, PAHs and metals.

Citing lifecycle studies, the alliance questioned whether switching to MGO would necessarily deliver better environmental outcomes.

“Assessments should compare complete fuel pathways, not a visible discharge against an alternative assumed to have no impact,” Chrysostomou said.

The proposed restrictions come amid a wider move to curb discharge of washwater from scrubbers.

Denmark, Sweden and Finland introduced bans on open-loop scrubber discharges in their territorial waters last year, while a separate restriction covering open-loop and hybrid scrubber washwater discharges in ports and inland waters across the North-East Atlantic region is due to take effect in mid-2027.