• Nobody asks where the crude in their VLSFO came from, but biofuel buyers want guarantees on feedstock
  • Industry must "get comfortable with advanced feedstocks under RED III Annex IX, because otherwise there will be significant inefficiencies". Working with a quality fuel supplier that you trust is central to this
  • Bunker Holding group: more than 1,500 alternative fuel deliveries, no quality claims "of any significance"
  • Certification is infrastructure too; Singapore's fuel standard and MFM mandate held up as the model
  • Conventional fuel still 91.7% of consumption; demand without regulation "almost non-existent"

Shipping needs to extend the trust it places in conventional fuel to biofuels made from advanced feedstocks, or it will run short of its preferred UCO-based product, according to KPI OceanConnect.

"When it comes to conventional fuel, our customers trust us completely," Jesper Sørensen, global head of alternative fuels and carbon markets at KPI OceanConnect, told Ship & Bunker in an interview at SIBCON in Singapore last month.

"No customer is coming to us when they buy VLSFO and saying the crude has to be from Saudi Arabia, otherwise no."

If there is a problem, the customer presents its case, the product is tested, and "as a reliable counterparty we take responsibility as per our terms and conditions", he said.

"The same principle doesn't quite seem to apply when it comes to biofuels."

The most sought-after biofuel is still UCO-based, he said, but demand for this product will eventually outstrip supply.

"The industry as a whole needs to embrace, or get comfortable with, alternative feedstocks or advanced feedstocks, because otherwise we will simply be short," he said.

"Not now, not tomorrow or the day after, but in time, as demand increases and regulatory environments shape up, the demand for biofuels will increase. It's simple math based on the orderbook."

Track Record

Sørensen’s belief in the safety of biofuel comes from a solid foundation.

He says KPI OceanConnect and parent Bunker Holding group have in-house technical experts on biofuels and LNG who work with engine makers and laboratories, and the group's delivery record reinforces the case for trust.

"Up until now we've done more than 1,500 alternative fuel deliveries across the board, and probably closer to 2,000 now, and we are yet to experience quality claims of any significance," he said.

"It's not to say there hasn't been an issue, but the one I can remember, when we tested the product, the bio portion wasn't the issue. It was the conventional part."

He said suppliers tell him the same.

But if what buyers are saying is any indication, there is still more to be done before they will put the same level of trust in biofuel as they do in conventional bunkers.

"Customers ask for guarantees on advanced feedstocks, and the answer is that the terms and conditions are the same for biofuel as for conventional fuel,” he said.

"We take responsibility for what we sell, and we believe in the product that we sell."

Certification

Asked about the potential for issues with biofuel blends following the Global Centre for Maritime Decarbonisation's recent finding that blend ratios are supplier-declared rather than independently verified, Sørensen said the answer lies in treating certification as part of the infrastructure.

"Infrastructure is not just physical infrastructure, it's not just terminals and storage and barges," he said.

"It is also certification, it is repeatability, it's credit. It's what Singapore does really well when it comes to fuels in general: they make a fuel standard and they adopt MFM."

There are places in the world with the problems GCMD describes, he said, which is why the group spends "a lot of time" vetting counterparties on the supply side as well as the customer side.

"When it comes to biofuels in particular, the physical product matters less, because from a sustainability point of view the documentation is what they use for the verification," he said.

"But of course there needs to be a responsibility in the industry, and that's up to us."

Most of the market relies on ISCC certification, he said, which is "probably not" perfect "but it provides some level of certainty.”

Of course the biggest question is, without a clear price advantage such as that seen recently in ARA, why else would buyers take the time to learn more about, and lift, biofuel?

Conventional fuel still accounts for over 90% of global in-scope consumption based on IMO’s DCS data, more than 90% of owners and operators pooled their FuelEU Maritime compliance last year, and there are only two real regulatory schemes, both in Europe, Sørensen noted.

"If you don't have that regulatory pressure, I think consumer demand and internal demand for decarbonisation remains quite low, if not almost non-existent," he said.